Home Addition vs. Remodel: Which Makes More Sense?

The Space Dilemma

You need more space. But should you add on or make better use of what you have? This decision affects your budget, timeline, and home value.

When to Remodel

Better choice if:

• You have underutilized space (basement, attic, garage)

• Layout is the problem, not square footage

• Budget is under $75,000

• You need results quickly

• Zoning limits additions

Typical costs: $50-$150 per square foot for interior remodel

When to Add On

Better choice if:

• You genuinely need more square footage

• Your lot can accommodate it

• The addition makes sense for your home's style

• You plan to stay long-term

Typical costs: $150-$300 per square foot for additions

Cost Comparison Example

Need a home office and extra bathroom:

Remodel Option: Convert formal dining room to office, update existing half-bath. Cost: $25,000-$40,000

Addition Option: Add 400 sq ft with office and full bath. Cost: $80,000-$120,000

ROI Considerations

Additions rarely return 100% of cost at resale. Over-improving for your neighborhood is a real risk. Remodels often have better ROI because you're improving existing space rather than adding cost.

Questions to Ask Yourself

• How long will we stay in this home?

• What's the neighborhood ceiling for home values?

• Is there space we're not using well?

• What's our realistic budget?

Our Recommendation

Start by maximizing your existing space. If that's not enough, then consider an addition. We can help you evaluate both options honestly.

Not sure which path is right? Contact Plymouth Builders for a free consultation.